Homemade vs Store-Bought Herbal Cough Syrup: What Actually Works

Homemade vs Store-Bought Herbal Cough Syrup: What Actually Works

November 13, 2026

By Montoya Sigafoose, founder of Home Remedy Shop

A homemade herbal cough syrup usually works as well as a store-bought one, and often better, because you control what goes in it. A good shop-bought syrup earns its place when you are too ill to cook or need something that keeps for months.

At Home Remedy Shop we have collected 20 homemade cough syrup recipes, and almost all of them start from the same base: raw honey. As I explain in our guide to honey for cough, honey coats the throat, calms the tickle and carries the herbs you add to it.

These syrups have been made in my family for three generations. Here is how homemade and store-bought compare, and how to pick well on either side.

Homemade vs store-bought at a glance

 

Homemade syrup

Store-bought herbal syrup

Ingredients

You choose: raw honey, fresh herbs, no fillers

Check the label: often glucose syrup, sugar, alcohol or flavourings

Strength

Fresh and potent, made for the cough you have

Standardised dose, usually milder

Shelf life

1 to 4 weeks in the fridge

Months, unopened

Cost

Very low, mostly kitchen ingredients

Moderate to high for good brands

Best for

Everyday coughs at home, families

Travel, busy weeks, when you are too ill to make it

Three homemade syrups that cover most coughs

1. Onion and honey syrup (for any cough). Slice one onion into a clean jar, cover with raw honey and leave for 4 to 8 hours. The onion releases its juice into the honey. Take one teaspoon as needed, up to five times a day.

2. Thyme, ginger and honey syrup (for a wet, phlegmy cough). Simmer a handful of fresh thyme and a thumb of sliced ginger in a cup of water for 10 minutes. Strain, let it cool until warm, then stir in an equal amount of raw honey. Thyme is the herb I trust most to loosen mucus.

3. Lemon, honey and licorice root syrup (for a dry, tickly cough). Steep a teaspoon of dried licorice root in hot water for 10 minutes, strain, cool, then add honey and the juice of half a lemon. It soothes an irritated throat lining.

Always stir honey into liquid that has cooled to warm, never boiling, so it keeps its natural enzymes.

How to choose a good store-bought herbal syrup

When you buy a herbal cough syrup online or in a pharmacy, read the label before the claims on the front:

  • Honey or herbal extract should be the first ingredient, not sugar or glucose syrup.
  • Look for proven traditional herbs: ivy leaf, thyme, marshmallow root, elderberry or licorice.
  • Avoid syrups built to suppress the cough if your cough is wet. You want to help it clear phlegm, not stop it.
  • Check the age guidance, especially for children.

Safety notes

Never give honey to a baby under 12 months, because of the risk of infant botulism. Licorice root is not for people with high blood pressure or during pregnancy. And if a cough lasts more than three weeks, comes with a high fever, or makes it hard to breathe, see a doctor.

FAQ

What are the most effective natural remedies for a persistent cough?

Raw honey, thyme tea, ivy leaf and steam are the most reliable. Match them to the cough: honey and licorice for a dry cough, thyme and ivy leaf for a wet one.

How do you make a homemade cough syrup with kitchen ingredients?

The simplest is onion and honey: cover a sliced onion with raw honey in a jar, wait a few hours and take a teaspoon of the syrup as needed.

Where can I buy quality ingredients for DIY cough remedies?

Raw honey from a local beekeeper, dried herbs such as thyme and licorice root from an organic herbalist or health shop, and fresh ginger and lemons from any greengrocer.

What are the best over-the-counter home remedies for cough relief?

Herbal syrups led by honey, ivy leaf or thyme, with no added sugar as the first ingredient, plus saline sprays and a humidifier.

Montoya Sigafoose is the founder of Home Remedy Shop, where she shares natural remedies that have worked in her family for three generations.