Changing Over the Locks Between Tenants: A Guide for Ottawa Valley Landlords

Changing Over the Locks Between Tenants: A Guide for Ottawa Valley Landlords

November 19, 2026


Every tenancy ends with a question many landlords answer too casually: what happens to the keys? A departing tenant hands back the copies they admit to having, but a key is trivially copied, and a landlord has no way of knowing how many are floating around after a year or two of roommates, partners, cleaners and dog-walkers. For rental owners in Arnprior, Braeside and across the Ottawa Valley, a disciplined lock changeover between tenants is basic risk management, not an optional extra.

Why collecting the keys back is not enough

Handing back keys proves nothing about copies. Hardware stores and kiosks cut duplicates in minutes, and no law requires a tenant to disclose them. The only way to guarantee that the previous occupant, and anyone they gave a key to, can no longer enter is to change what the existing keys open.

There are two ways to do that, and they are not the same.

Rekey or replace? The landlord's decision

Rekeying keeps the existing lock body but changes the internal pins so the old keys no longer work and a new key is issued. It is fast, keeps matched hardware, and is the usual choice when the locks themselves are in good condition.

Replacing swaps the entire lock and is the right call when hardware is worn, damaged, mismatched, or when you want to upgrade the grade of lock.

For most turnovers, the practical answer is to rekey the locks rather than replace them, reserving replacement for hardware that is failing or being upgraded. A locksmith can tell at a glance which doors need which.

Build it into the turnover checklist

Treat the lock changeover as a fixed line item between tenancies, alongside cleaning and painting:

  • Rekey or replace every exterior door the tenant had a key to, including side, basement and garage man-doors.
  • Check patio and window locks while the unit is empty.
  • Change or reset any keypad or smart-lock codes.
  • Update mailbox and common-area keys where applicable.
  • Record the new key code and how many keys were issued.

Doing this while the unit is vacant is faster and simpler to schedule than fitting it around a new tenant's move-in day.

Multi-unit buildings: think about key control

Owners of a duplex, triplex or small apartment building face a harder problem: a drawer full of keys that open who-knows-what. A master key system brings order by letting each tenant's key open only their own unit while a single management key opens common areas, so a turnover means rekeying one suite rather than puzzling over a tangle of unlabelled keys. Best K Locksmith designs and rekeys master-keyed systems for Ottawa Valley rental properties.

Know the ground rules in Ontario

Under Ontario's residential tenancy rules, a landlord generally may not change the locks during a tenancy without giving the tenant a new key, and a tenant may not change the locks without the landlord's consent. The clean, uncontroversial moment to change the locks is after one tenancy ends and before the next begins, when the unit is vacant. If a mid-tenancy situation arises, such as a lost master key or a safety concern, it is worth confirming your obligations before acting.

A standing relationship helps

Landlords who manage several units benefit from a locksmith who already knows their buildings. A property management lock service can keep records of what is keyed how, respond between tenancies, and handle emergencies without starting from scratch each time. Best K Locksmith works with rental owners across the Ottawa Valley on exactly this kind of ongoing basis.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I legally have to change the locks between tenants? Ontario's rules do not force a changeover between tenancies, but they do protect a sitting tenant's access during one. The gap between tenancies is the clean window to rekey, and doing so protects you and the incoming tenant.

Is rekeying as secure as a new lock? For a lock in good condition, yes. Rekeying changes the pins so old keys no longer work, which is the security outcome you need. Replacement matters when the hardware itself is worn or being upgraded.

Can I just change the codes on a smart lock instead? For a keypad or smart lock, resetting the codes and removing old user profiles achieves the same goal electronically, provided there is no mechanical key override still cut to the old key.

How quickly can a turnover be done? A typical unit's exterior doors can usually be rekeyed in a single visit while the unit is vacant. Scheduling it as part of the standard turnover avoids last-minute pressure.

Why use Best K Locksmith for a rental portfolio? Because an ongoing relationship means your buildings' keying is documented and a changeover or emergency can be handled without re-explaining the setup each time.